Showing posts with label pork. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pork. Show all posts

Sunday, August 14, 2011

2011-12 Budget Pork - The Whole 9 Yards

It's getting time to fish or cut bait. We've taken a good hard look at the proposed/draft 2011-12 SPASD budget, and we find a number of budget lines to be potentially low hanging fruit...ripe for the pickin'.

Download a PDF copy of SP-EYE Analysis of the 2011-12 SPASD Budget  
 Maybe we don't have it right...we can admit it when we make an error...but it places the burden of proof squarely upon the district. PROVE to the community that you absolutely need all that is budgeted, and you have our support.

 Otherwise...get your pencils sharpened. We believe quite strongly that we can fund at least the first two initiatives recommended by the district, and still get the tax levy increase down to 2.5% or less.


Pork Also Found in the Fund 27 Budget; Film At 11

Many of you will initially ask, "What's Fund 27?  I thought there was just Fund 10, the General Fund"?
Well, boys and girls, Fund 27 is the Special Education budget for each school district.

OK, you're gasping...aren't you?  Just like no one expects the Spanish inquisition, no one pokes the sacred cow.   Right?  Wrong! Stop being a bunch of namby pambies.  These are YOUR tax dollars.  The district is sure to quickly come to the defense of special education, adding a smoke screen to what we really want you to see.  Get off it!  Nobody is attacking Special Education.  We understand and value the services provided for our special needs children.  So let's just nip that one in the bud, eh?   We only want to look at ONE part of the budget.  So let's all be adult about it.

12.5% of the General Fund goes to fund Special Ed
The district is quick to gloss over the "other" funds, like Food Service and Special Education, by declaring that the district tax levy comes only from the General Fund (Fund 10).  But what we cannot lose sight of the simple fact that the district transfers over $9,000,000 dollars into the Special Ed fund (Fund 27) annually.  That amounts to 12.5% of the General Fund.  Nothing to sneeze at!

So if we're not off poking the sacred cow, what's our point?  The point is that just like the regular education budget, the special ed budget includes specific line item costs for staff salaries, and fringes...including health insurance!  So...if we're looking at--and finding budgetary fluff--in the health insurance line of Fund 10, we also have to look at that line item in Fund 27.  After all, Fund 10 provides 70% of the entire revenue needs for Fund 27.

Then why the two orders? Colonel?
Why is it that for the general fund, the budget document shows a 1.20% increase for health insurance, but for the Special Education budget, it shows a 7.39% increase for 2011-12???  Employees DO pay the same share of their health insurance costs regardless of which program they belong too, right?

What's the bottom line
The total proposed budget for health insurance in the General Fund is $8.3M...and we believe there to be at least $220,000 excess in that.  Therefore, with a Special Ed health insurance budgeted mount of $2.45M, don't tell us that there's not at least $75,000 extra in there as well.

Saturday, August 13, 2011

Simplifying the Health Insurance Budget Issue

No matter how you slice it, there sure looks to be at least $200,000 of "room to maneuver within the budget for health insurance premiums.  That's more than enough to fund the entire $165,00 desired to spend on RTI  Math and Reading tutoring.

We've received feedback that all the numbers are confusing.  So, in an attempt to try to help clarify the issue, try this...let's look at the 4 classes of employees and see how health insurance changes impact the budget.  Remember, there are two factors at work here:

  1.  Insurance premium costs are increasing by 3.5%...so the district WILL incur more cost.
  2. Now all employee groups will pay 9% of their premiums (10% if they do not participate in a Health Risk Assessment program).


28.5 Administrators - 0.86% Savings
In 2010-11, Administrators paid 5% of their premiums (6%  if they do not participate in a Health Risk Assessment program).
The cost of premiums is increasing by 3.5%
Administrators are paying at least a 4% higher share of their premium  (9% - 5%)
Net effect:  0.5% SAVINGS  (Actually it's 0.86% but let's call it a wash for argument sake)

30.4 Administrative Support - 0.86% Savings
In 2010-11, Administrative Support paid 5% of their premiums (6%  if they do not participate in a Health Risk Assessment program).
The cost of premiums is increasing by 3.5%
Administrative Support are paying at least a 4% higher share of their premium  (9% - 5%)
Net effect:  0.5% SAVINGS (Actually it's 0.86% but let's call it a wash for argument sake)

324 Local 60 (Support) Staff -  3.5% increased cost
In 2010-11, Local 60 already were  paying 9% of their premiums
The cost of premiums is increasing by 3.5%
0% savings from increased share of premium costs.
Net effect:  3.5% INCREASED COSTS 

561 SPEA (Teaching Staff) - 4.57% Savings
In 2010-11, SPEA members paid only 1.3% of their premiums.
The cost of premiums is increasing by 3.5%
SPEA are paying at a 7.7% higher share of their premium (9% - 1.3%)
Net effect: 4.2% SAVINGS (Actually it's 4.57% )

The first $212,418 of health insurance budget fluff
So...clearly, the savings outweigh the increased costs...right?  Therefore, there's no way that the budgeted health insurance premiums (line 240) can be MORE than what we spent last year... we should be able to agree on that, right?

That means that since we spent $8,100,185 for 2010-11 and we're budgeting $8,322,603 for 2011-12, then we can take $222,418 right off the top.

SPEA Members yield the most significant savings
Last year the cost of health insurance premiums for SPEA members was about $6,500,000. The district's share of that cost was about 1.3%, or $6,415,500 Using our basic math, we can adjust the base cost for the 2011-12 premium rate increase (3.5%).  $6.500,000 X 1.035 = $6,727,500. The district's share of that cost for 2011-12 is 91%, or $6,122,025. The difference between the district's cost for 2010-11 vs. 2011-12 is a savings of $293,475 

Add in increased costs for Local 60 members
In 2010-11, the district paid about $3,500,000 for Local 60 health insurance.  Since Local 60 has been paying 9% all along, there is no savings.  We do, however have to factor in the additional district cost for premium increases,  With a 3.5% premium cost increase, the district will bear an additional $122,500 in costs for 2011-12.

 Now add in the health insurance costs for staff additions
The district (obviously) didn't pay anything for the cost of new staff additions added for 2011-12 so these costs must be considered and subtracted from any net savings.  The budget documents made available to the public to date indicate that 14 new staff will be added based on projected enrollment increases.  Just as obviously, if actual enrollment exceeds projections, this number may increase.

The district's share of a cost of a family health plan is $14,270. The district's share of a cost of a single health plan is $5,489. Typically 67% of stff choose the family plan, 21% choose the single plan, and the rest opt for an "alternate" benefit plan which pays them $3,600 per year to take neither plan. For simplification and to factor in a little budget leeway, let's assume that 11 new staff choose the family plan and 3 choose the single plan. 11 x $14,271 = $156,978 3 x $ 5,489 = $ 16,466 Total new cost = $173,444

 Adding it all up, it appears that there is about $220,000 more than necessary budgeted for health insurance.