Showing posts with label district office. Show all posts
Showing posts with label district office. Show all posts

Saturday, August 13, 2011

STILL More Questionable Information Coming From the School District!

When is the school board going to address the cost of poor quality information coming out of the district office?

This past Monday, at the school board's FTT meeting, we heard the district's recommendation that school board meetings be moved from the Municipal Building, which seems to be good enough to stream and televise live City Council meetings...  but perhaps not good enough for the district.

As is too often the case, we quickly learned that the District has not done its due diligence in determining whether such a move is truly feasible, or what the true cost of making such a move would be. Luckily, Sun Prairie Media Center (SPMC, formerly Sun Prairie Cable Access TV) Executive Director Cameron Thompson pointed out several things the District does not appear to have considered:

 1. The live feed is located in the gymnasium at CHUMS — requiring cable to be run from the gymnasium to the auditorium.
 2. The purchase microphones and a camera to broadcast meetings at CHUMS would be required; costs not considered.
3. When Sun Prairie Media Center broadcast from CHUMS previously, the cable end experienced at least one problem during the broadcast each year.

  What about Seniors and Those that Are not Internet Savvy? 
The plans to move school board and committee meetings from the municipal building also mean that meetings would no longer be available to watch live via Charter cable as the meeting is held. SPMC would broadcast the tapes later on, but live viewing would no longer be possible by TV. Many district residents are not savvy enough o lack the internet bandwidth to watch streaming video. Many have gotten used to watching the meetings live on Charter cable. Why would the district now consider turning its back on the very citizens that financed this district for many, many years.
   Read the STAR's coverage

Burning Questions
When will the district stop bringing forward information which has not been properly vetted? 


How can the school board vote to approve any decision based on bad data? 

 The school board's vision statement includes using data to drive decision-making. How can that work when the quality of information is poor? Poor quality data leads to poor decisions.

Saturday, September 20, 2008

Appearances are everything

At the September 8th meeting of the School Board's Finance Committee, citizen representative Rick Mealy requested more information about check number 88669 to a local lawn care firm. Getting insufficient answers to his questions from Business Services Manager Rhonda Page, Mealy contacted Tom Brooks, the District Buildings and Grounds Manager. Brooks indicated,
"We called them for a quote and the quote seemed very reasonable for the removal and stump grinding. We were happy with the way they performed at SOAR, so when we needed two more removed at Ashley we called them again. They again responded quickly and cleaned up after themselves. I would anticipate calling them again if the need arises. "

Again, Mealy's questions were not completely answered. So...on to a little detective work. There was no website for the firm, but there was a yellow page ad in the Sun Prairie phone book. A Google search of the company's phone number revealed that the phone number was also the home phone number of someone with the same unusual name as a certain member of the SPASD District Administration.

In a pre-Finance Committee meeting discussion with board member Terry Shimek, Shimek understood the underlying concern about the district contracting out for business with family members. But he seemed to be the only one who knew of the situation and understood the potential gravity. Interestingly enough, Phil Frei, Rhonda Page, and school board member/ Finance Committee chair, Jim McCourt all indicated that they had no idea that a familial relationship existed between a school district administrator and the local lawn care firm.

What is at issue here is not the quality of the work performed or even the price of the work performed. The underlying theme that the school board and district do not seem to understand is the need to conduct business in a manner which ensures against any potential conflicts of interest.

Even for such a small amount ($1450), if the district even considered having the firm in question perform the work, they SHOULD have accepted at least two other bids and gone with the most competitive bid. Only doing business in that manner could the board and the district escape the questions that continually gnaw at the root of trust. The fact that other district staff presumably had no knowledge of any relationship only adds further fuel to a smoldering fire.

Sunday, August 17, 2008

$50K to move board meetings?

The Sun Prairie school board is inching ever closer to its targeted goal line - to move the location of its meetings from the City Municipal building to the District Office.

Of course, making such a move is going to cost money: at least $45-50,000.

Alternative 1: Cost: $50,,000 + Cable connection to library for TV broadcasting. Move School Board meetings to Room 100 at the District Office, and duplicate the equipment at City Hall

Alternative 2: Cost: $34,000 + Cable connection to library for TV broadcasting. Move School Board meetings to Room 100 at the District Office, but with less equipment than is at City Hall.

Alternative 3: Cost: $ 350. Install wireless network access at City Hall for School Board meetings.

Why they'll tell you it won't cost this much.
The Partial Truth police are on full alert. The costs of various items are not all incorporated into the original figures on the FTT Situation report.

Concerns that neither the board nor the FTT committee has adequately addressed.
  • Given the economy and the projected rise in budget as is, why move meetings from City Hall? $50,000 would pay for a position or a lot of textbooks.

  • Aren't we supposed to have a "partnering relationship" with the City and City Council? Why would we NOT want to share a facility?

  • The board keeps preaching streaming video over the Internet for its meetings rather than cable, and the fact that many residents don't have access to KSUN-TV. Great. But how many people have a slower Internet connection...like, say, a phone modem...and will never be able to watch streaming video coherently.

  • This whole proposal is linked to the board's previous purchase of BoardDocs software and laptop computers for all board members. The school district has demonstrated a less than stellar comprehension of Internet technology. Do we REALLY want to sink more $$$ into this project before we really see how it works?

    • District staff lack technological savvy. The District currently pays someone to scan existing documents (which are nearly always created with Microsoft Office software) and put them into an Adobe Acrobat Reader file (PDF) as IMAGES..rather than searchable test. Not only does this make board packages phenomenally large ( have you tried to download one?) but it is completely user UNfriendly because one cannot search through the documents to find the information one seeks.

    • The BoardDocs software is only a tool. The end user has to make the tool effective. Currently the School Board's website lacks any sense of organization. Sure...you can find minutes from school board meeting from the 1990's. But how does one find contracts like those for to find out what we are paying personnel? How does one find information associated with past decisions...particularly contentious ones? If we can't organize files on the existing website, it won't happen with BoardDocs either.
    • Has anyone given any thought to how this BoardDocs and meetings over the web will work for people with accessibility problems: hearing impaired? visual impaired?

Technology is great. But technology opens up a whole new set of doors behind which are a whole host of issues that need to be addressed. All that costs more money.